The model consists of a planet on which black and white daisies are growing. The java interface comes with a link to a student activity page in pdf format. In this case the mep will predict that the temperature will adjust close to t g, while the gaia. As it was impossible to fully represent how the biota and its environment are coupled on earth, lovelock 1983a, 1983b offered a simple parable. Daisyworld exercise student exercise kirsten menking. Beyond these generally accepted facts, the gaia hypothesis advances three central propositions. Daisyworld is an imaginary planet, which receives energy from a star that is similar to the earths sun and is populated by two species of daisy, black and white, the 1gaia is an ancient greek name for the earth goddess. In response, lovelock contended that, in no way is this gaia theory.
Chapter 11 contains a large collection of exercises to draw general lessons from daisyworld and the concept of the span of control. The daisyworld model created by andrew watson and james lovelock 1983, tellus, v. In daisyworld, natural selection can both generate and contribute to. It is possible to make a small change to the 2d daisyworld so that gaia and mep cannot be satisfied simultaneously. The daisy world model is intended to illustrate a mechanism through which according to the gaian hypothesis biota might optimize their abiotic environment by means of negative feedback. The gaia hypothesis can be understood through the simple computer model daisyworld, which was developed for the purpose. The gaia hypothesis states that the earths biosphere interacts with and regulates the physical conditions of the planet. This also serves as an effective example of negative and positive feedback. For high school student, college student, and general audience.
Lovelock, 1983, biological homeostasis of the global environment. Only through stressing the unconscious nature of this regulation particular with reference to daisyworld has the gaia hypothesis been able to refute. Nov 12, 2019 daisyworld demonstrating the gaia hypothesis. In this chapter we develop the basic model postulated by james lovelock and lynn margulis to explore the gaia hypothesis the put forward in the 1960s and 1970s as an explanation for the processes by which living organisms create the conditions suitable for habitation of life on a planet. A star like our sun will take something like 10 billion years to run. The gaia theory suggests that the earth behaves like a single organism and the biosphere has a selfregulatory e ect on the earths environment. Gaia theory the gaia hypothesis, when we introduced it in the 1970s supposed that the atmosphere, the oceans, the climate, and the crust of the earth are regulated at a state comfortable for life because of the behavior of living organisms. The original daisyworld gave credit to the gaia hypothesis by. Daisyworld as an interesting mathematical model in its own right. Bachelor project mathematics university of groningen. Lovelock and colleagues tested this ancillary hypothesis on a scientific cruise between england and antarctica.
Daisyworld, a computer simulation, is a hypothetical world orbiting a star whose radiant energy is slowly increasing or decreasing. The gaia hypothesis, in its strongest form, states that the earths atmosphere, oceans, and biota form a tightly coupled system that maintains environmental conditions close to optimal for life. A model commonly used to examine the global emergent properties proposed by the gaia hypothesis is daisyworld. It may inform the debate on gaia, but they are not inextricably tied. By mark wittwer environmental engineering project 640. The first exercise is a verification exercise, so you will. Also, because of its simplicity netlogo will enable a larger number of daisies to be simulated on daisyworld. Gaia hypothesis was used to make predictions for example, that marine organisms would make volatile compounds that can transfer essential elements from the ocean back to the land. The analysis of such systems is not a trivial problem, even for the highly simplified situation on daisyworld.
The daisyworld equations form a system of nonlinear, multiple feedback loops. Modeling the earth daisyworld in the 1970s scientist james lovelock introduced the gaia hypothesis, in which he proposed that the earth is a selfregulating system governed by the. Some information on the steady state behaviour of the equations can, however, be obtained without a disproportionate amount of mathematical effort. The daisyworld model has attracted considerable interest from the scientific community and has now established itself as a model independent of, but still related to, the gaia theory. However, even in the curvedplanet version of 2d daisyworld ackland et al. A model that is often used to illustrate the original gaia hypothesis is the socalled daisyworld simulation. Whether this sort of system is present on earth is still open to debate. For each level of insolation, the daisyworld where bb is the densitydependent inhibitory evect model computes the planetary temperature using ofblackdaisiesonblackdaisies,wbisthecompetithe stefanboltzmann law for black body radi tive evect of white daisies on black daisies, and so ation and the average planetary albedo.
The idea that life on earth regulates the physical and. Daisyworld was invented by james lovelock, to explain how the gaia hypothesis does not require a sentient earth, but only feedback loops, for homeostasis. Daisyworld is in fact the mathematical basis of gaia theory. This dynamic geophysiology is illustrated by daisyworld, a planet in which the earth. James lovelocke talks about gaia theory and the daisyworld model. A critical investigation of the relationship between. Life itself could maintain the planet fit for life within limits. Some of this work has been produced in response to criticism of the gaia hypothesis and daisyworld specifically and some has been produced by using daisyworld as a testbed to explore a range of issues. This simulator includes the classic daisyworld and a 3d daisyball variant, with usercontrolled parameters. The gaia hypothesis examines the global effects of local interactions among organisms. It might seem that the great stability of these geophysiological models is in contradiction to the inherent instability leading to deterministic chaos, which is a general property to evolving systems of. Oct 31, 2012 a simplification of lovelocks model in support of the gaia hypothesis. This model is important in the development of daisyworld as more recently. Maximization principles and daisyworld sciencedirect.
This thesis examines the daisyworld control system and in doing so explains how daisyworld performs homeostasis. The gaia hypothesis properly defined this hospitality as a full homeostasis. At the beginning of daisyworld time, its sun provides 550 wm 2 and by the end of daisyworld time, its sun gives off 1650 wm 2. The gaia hypothesis, also known as gaia theory or gaia principle, proposes that all organisms and their inorganic surroundings. The gaia hypothesis holds that earths physical and biological processes are linked to form a complex, selfregulating system and that life has affected this system over time. Daisyworld or gaia redux the only bad theories are those that cannot be questioned or tested james lovelock you have by now read most of james lovelocks book gaia a new look at life on earth, and have read about his key thesis that organic life was not a passive passenger on the third rock from the sun, but had an active role in shaping the earths climate and.
A gaian system g302 development of the global environment the gaia hypothesis ranges of influence. The original gaia hypothesis proposed that life on earth, along with the oceans, atmosphere and crust, forms a homeostatic system which reduces the effects of external perturbations, so that conditions are maintained to within the range that allows widespread life. While evolving, life forms on earth modulate their environment temperature, etc. Specifically, the gaia hypothesis said that the temperature. Daisyworld is an imaginary grey world orbiting, at a similar distance to the earth, a star like our sun that gets brighter with time. Scientists debate gaia is a multidisciplinary reexamination of the gaia hypothesis, which was introduced by james lovelock and lynn margulis in the early 1970s. It is meant to mimic important elements of the earthsun system, and was introduced by james lovelock and andrew watson in a paper published in 1983 to illustrate the plausibility of the gaia hypothesis. The gaia hypothesis, also known as gaia theory or gaia principle, proposes that all. This model describes an imaginary planet called daisyworld see figure below. Daisyworld examines the energy budget of a planet populated by two different types of plants, black daisies and white daisies. I pointed out that the singular term, the gaia hypothesis, was being applied to many different propositions, ranging from. Observations of planetary mep are presumed to indicate that largescale atmospheric heat transfer mechanisms are selforganizing.
Exploring the nature of environmental feedback in daisyworld. Gaia, the idea that life moderates the global environment to make it more favorable for life, was first introduced in 1972 in an academic paper titled gaia as seen through the atmosphere in the journalatmospheric environment, followed rapidly by two other papers both in 1974. Its original form was introduced by james lovelock as a defense against criticism that his gaia theory of the earth as a self. Organisms can greatly affect their environments, and the feedback coupling between organisms and their environments can shape the evolution of both. A question to be answered while investigating the daisyworld model is how varying the changes in luminosity of the sun affects the effectiveness of the daisies to regulate global temperature. This entails making the death rate temperature dependent, and the temperature for minimum death rate t d different from that for maximum birthrate t g. Fact, theory, and wishful thinking 393 clarify and focus the gaia debate, which seemed to be at risk of becoming a shouting match between disciples and detractors.
There has been a lot of criticism on the gaia theory and daisyworld was presented to defend the gaia theory. In the original 1983 version, daisyworld is seeded with two. The extra exercises here focus on the role of time lags in the flowers response to changes in temperature. Daisyworlds sun begins it life with a diminished luminosity like all suns and grows steadily hotter and hotter, producing more and more energy. Daisyworld thus provides a mathematical basis for studying the gaia hypothesis 9. Based on a simple scenario, daisyworld envisages a world with two types of daisies, black and white. Gaia, the grand idea 3 ested skeptics in a wideranging scientific discussion of the hypothesis. This hypothesis has been largely misinterpreted, with many. Daisyworld s sun begins it life with a diminished luminosity like all suns and grows steadily hotter and hotter, producing more and more energy. Daisyworld is a simple mathematical model intended to demonstrate certain aspects of this planetary homeostasis. In the 1970s scientist james lovelock introduced the gaia hypothesis, in which he proposed that the earth is a selfregulating system governed by the interactions of myriad organisms with the atmosphere, hydrosphere, rocks, and soils.
In the 1970s scientist james lovelock introduced the gaia hypothesis, in which. The original paper by watson and lovelock introducing the daisyworld. The following is a direct excerpt from university of wales model description. The original daisyworld relies on a deterministic set of equations to determine the outcome of the model. Nov 17, 2009 james lovelocke talks about gaia theory and the daisyworld model. Two different organisms, white and black daisies, grow on. Gaia hypothesis 1 gaia hypothesis the study of planetary habitability is partly based upon extrapolation from knowledge of the earths conditions, as the earth is the only planet currently known to harbour life. There have been many offshoots to other areas of science, including nonlinear dynamics, ecosystem and food web theory, evolutionary theory, physiology, maximum entropy production, and artificial life. This first chapter introduces the gaia hypothesis and two competing hypotheses. The daisyworld model was first proposed and implemented by lovelock and andrew watson. I extend the daisyworld model that has underpinned much of the early modelling work on the gaia hypothesis. Daisyworld in the 1970s scientist james lovelock introduced the gaia hypothesis, in which he proposed that the earth is a selfregulating system governed by the interactions of myriad organisms with the atmosphere, hydrosphere, rocks, and.
984 773 775 1392 759 702 918 991 1467 512 770 1008 1015 673 479 108 1092 707 647 695 1236 609 19 207 523 678 382 648 505 409